Don't miss a single recipe from Picky Palate: sign up for my weekly newsletter


Nutter Butter White Chocolate Chip Cookies

How was everybody’s Thanksgiving Weekend? What a feast, there’s nothing like good ol’ traditional Thanksgiving dinner. We stuffed ourselves as usual with about everything imaginable. It was fun indeed! Back to heated yoga asap.

Ok, so who else tackled Black Friday? I can’t believe I’m going to fess up to waking up early and standing in line at Target with my mother before 6am. We had so much fun dashing to the items on our list. We walked away with everything we wanted. My mother is ruthless. Girlfriend was running through the isles like a woman on a mission for her Guitar Hero! We had more than a few good laughs.

I feel like a weight has been lifted off my shoulders after last week. I took both of my pilates exams and feel pretty good about them. Now I have to wait 6 weeks for my results. Who would have thought that being a Stott Pilates instructor was so much work?!. I swear I studied nearly as much for this test as I did for my dental hygiene boards 7 years ago. There is something seriously wrong with that. Or maybe it was just harder trying to study with kids this time around. Whatever the case, I did it and it feels so good!

Here’s another fun cookie I’ve had on file that is flat out incredible. These are perfect for those upcoming Holiday Plates for your family and friends. Check em’ out and enjoy!

Nutter Butter White Chocolate Chip Cookies

2 sticks butter

1 Cup peanut butter

1 Cup sugar

1 Cup brown sugar

2 egg

1 teaspoon vanilla

2 ½ Cups flour

1 ½ teaspoons baking soda

½ teaspoon baking powder

½ teaspoon salt

1 Cup white chocolate chips

10 Nutter Butter Cookies broken into small pieces

1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Cream the butter and sugars until well combined. Add in peanut butter until well combined. With mixer on low beat in eggs and vanilla until smooth.

2. Sift flour, baking soda and powder, and salt into a large bowl. With mixer on low slowly add in dry ingredients, white chips and broken Nutter Butters until just combined.

3. With a medium cookie scoop, scoop cookie dough onto a parchment or silpat lined baking sheet. Bake for 9-11 minutes or until cookies are cooked through but still soft. Let cool for 3 minutes on baking sheet before transferring to a cooling rack to cool. Serve and enjoy!

about 36 cookies

Have a Great Week Everybody! More treats to come!

Follow me on instagram

FOLLOW PICKY PALATE ON INSTAGRAM! Show me what recipes you're making from Picky Palate by using #pickypalate.

Comments Leave a Reply
Print Recipe Print Recipe

Powered by MailChimp

Other recipes you may enjoy...


45 Responses | Comments RSS

  1. 1
    HoneyB says:

    There are few boughten cookies that I like, but nutter butter is one I DO like! Sounds like something my Grumpy would eat!

  2. 2
    Clumbsy Cookie says:

    Glad you had a good time at Thanksgiving! Now these cookies are right up my alley: nutty and sweet! Enjoy the rest of the sunday!

  3. 3
    carol says:

    We had Thanksgiving at my daughter’s house-then I cooked a turkey here on Friday….talk about leftovers-YIKES! That’s the best part to me. No-I didn’t brave the crowds of shoppers on Black Friday….Robin did-and got some great deals…she started and just about finished Christmas shopping. In her words, she couldn’t afford NOT to go shopping that day.
    I’m adding your cookies to my ever growing list of recipes-they look and sound fantastic! You’re making my holiday baking a lot easier, Jenny!
    Also glad that the Pilates exams are over for you-now the wait to get the results…I’m sure you’re breathing a big AHHHHHHH-one more thing to knock off the list…

  4. 4
    Lisa says:

    I’m sure my kids would love these. Congrats on finishing your exams. I’m sure you did well.

  5. 5
    Tanya says:

    I just love white chocolate..these look great!

  6. 6
    Meg says:

    What amazing cookies! YUM! I am sure you did great on the Pilates test!

  7. 7
    Jenny says:

    Great Shelby, I hope Grumpy loves them!

    Thanks Rita! Hope your Thanksgiving was nice as well!

    Hi Carol,
    I like Robin’s thinking. I agree with her, that I couldn’t afford not to go shopping Friday! Thanks for your sweet words!

    Thanks Lisa!

    Thanks Tanya and Meg!

  8. 8
    Bob says:

    Congratz on finishing your tests, that’s always a good feeling. Mmmm, cookies within cookies. Good times. 🙂

  9. 9
    Mary says:

    Congratulations on completing your exams. It must be a relief to have them over before the big move. The cookies look fantastic.

  10. 10
    Ashley says:

    We went shopping on Black Friday. Target was our third stop so we didn’t get there until about 7:30am, but everything we wanted was still in stock! That was including a cookware set and a Xbox 360. We were amazed!

  11. 11
    Sara says:

    As usual, these cookies look wonderful! Black Friday is so much fun. I headed down to Scottsdale at about 6:30am and was done with my list of shopping by noon.

  12. 12
    That Girl says:

    I can’t believe you braved Black Friday! We hit the stores around 12/1 and managed to do okay.

  13. 13
    Sara says:

    These cookies sound great, I love white chocolate, I bet it’s good with peanut butter.

  14. 14
    Dawn says:

    I can’t believe you tackled black friday…I would be scared.
    Did you save big time? I saw that Target had way better deals than Walmart.
    Great cookies…I love Nutter Butters!

  15. 15
    priscilla says:

    hi jenny! good to see you back, i missed your posts. these cookies look so good, i am going to have to try them. i made your milky way cookies and my family loved them. my Dad thought they were soo good.
    i know this may sound kinda dumb, but what is pilates?

  16. 16
    Kaitlin says:

    These look so good and buttery..yumm! Glad you had a good Thanksgiving! =)

  17. 17
    CookiePie says:

    Those cookies look and sound fabulous! Congrats on finishing your exams — I’m sure you aced them 🙂

  18. 18
    Katrina says:

    These look great. Love a Nutter Butter and ya might as well put them in a cookie, just like Oreos.

  19. 19
    Leslie says:

    My husband can’t wait for me to try these. I REALLY think you should come out with a cookbook! Everything that I make from your site is point on. My husband calls me a “food snob” because I am so particular and like good food. Girl – you know good food.

    Here is a challenge for you…I have an 18month adorable little boy who is allergic to egg. I don’t want him left out of the Christmas goodies. Any good “eggless” treats up your sleeve?

  20. 20
    Leslie says:

    Ohhh.those look scary good! Whats not to love.
    I am sure you did great on your tests!And you are a crazy woman to do Black Friday!

  21. 21
    Candy says:

    Yum! I bet Christmas will be fun at your house this year. Enjoy the years of buying toys. My guys “toys” are getting very, very, very expensive!

  22. 22
    Aggie says:

    Oooooh…nutter butters are the best!! Glad you got past last week, now you can relax and go do some yoga! I had to hit the gym hard this weekend after all my indulgences this past week!!

    You cookies look fantastic, you come up with the best recipes!

  23. 23
    Patsyk says:

    My Husband was out very early on Black Friday… I stayed home and slept! 🙂

    Studying w/kids is so much harder! I’m always impressed with anyone who can do it.

    those cookies look so yummy! Can you send some my way? 😉

  24. 24
    Brindi says:

    Thanks for this recipe! My husband loves Nutter Butter cookies. He is going to love these!

  25. 25
    Pam says:

    Hope you did well on your pilates exams. The cookies look fantastic!

  26. 26
    Allie says:

    You won be over with the nutter butter in the title! I’m sure you did fine on your exam, but I know it’s stressful waiting for the results.

  27. 27
    Maria says:

    The cookies look great! Glad you had a nice Thanksgiving and good luck with the pilates exam!!

  28. 28
    My Sweet & Saucy says:

    Congrats on finishing the pilates test! I definitely need some instruction after this holidays eating feast!

  29. 29
    Threeundertwo says:

    Yum! These sound delicious!

    Good luck with the Pilates, waiting for the results must be the hardest part.

  30. 30
    Live.Love.Eat says:

    Kudos to you for braving Black Friday. Can’t do it myself. But I do like the looks of these cookies!!!!!

  31. 31
    Patti says:

    I was up by 3:18 to hit Kohl’s by 4:00, to WalMart by 5:00 and Target by 6:00! Madness!
    These cookies look like they’re going to make it to my cookie plate this season 🙂

  32. 32
    Jake and Heidi says:

    how do you stay so skinny?! I would love to know! your food looks yummy!

  33. 33
    Bunny says:

    I’m so glad that your rough week is over so you can relax…do moms relax?? LOL!! I love this cookie and I know my hubby will he LOVES PB!!

  34. 34
    ConversationsWithACupcake says:

    The first time I ever had Nutter Butters was at my Aunt Florence’s house, and I was–right then– an addict.

    I’m SO making these. And stashing them away for just. me.

    (Is that against the Holiday spirit?)

  35. 35
    Sharon says:

    Good for you for getting out there and scoring some bargains!! These cookies look absolutely amazing. A combination of all the best things in life 🙂

  36. 36
    Emily says:

    Guilty! Man Jenny you got to sleep in! We were in the stores by 4 am! insane I know! Who started this insane tradition! If we had any sense we would wake up, finish a pie for breakfast and lounge in jams all day!
    I just love your cookies! They are always d-lish!

  37. 37
    Cristine says:

    Wow… that’s all… just WOW! 🙂

  38. 38
    Zesty Cook says:

    Great looking cookies! I would love them.


  39. 39
    Tasty Trends says:

    congrats on finishing your pilates test! i am sure you did well!

    your nutterbutter cookies look great!

  40. 40
    Anne says:

    Those look wonderful! Good luck on your exams- I’m sure you’ll do great! I’m glad you guys got everything at black friday (I wish someone would buy me guitar hero, lol!)

  41. 41
    Deborah says:

    You can’t go wrong when you add nutter butters!

  42. 42
    Jullee and Fam says:

    This was such a good cookie!! I made them for my husband to take to work and one of his co-workers sat there and ate all but two of them!! He said they were yummier than he expected so he had to keep eating!

    I substituted the white chocolate chips for semi sweet and they were so great!

  43. 43
    Jill says:

    I made these yesterday and they were amazing. I took them to work and they disappeared in minutes! Thanks for the great recipe!

  44. 44

    […] the cookies I made today! They’re Nutter Butter Chip. I got the recipe from Picky Palate and just made a few slight adjustments based on what I had in the house. Farewell holiday baking.. […]

  45. 45

    cell phones…

    Sweet post! Have a fantastic time.and our web site as well just about cell phones!…

Jenny Flake

Welcome to Picky Palate, my online kitchen! You'll usually find me with a cookie in one hand and a salad in the other. It's all about the balance :) The recipes you'll see are my creations. The Picky Palate Cookbook is now available. Enjoy!