Leave a Reply
Add to Recipe Box
Print Recipe
Oh dear, I have no explanation for this dessert. None at all. They should actually be illegal, but what the heck I will share the recipe with you anyway
Last Sunday night, the boys and I were playing in the kitchen and that’s when these pies were born. If you follow me on Instagram (pickypalate) you got a sneak peek of them
Talk about decadent, cute and wrong! Lol, I give you my Oreo and Peanut Butter Layered Lattice Pies…..enjoy!
Well, you won’t need a whole lot for the recipe, just some peanut butter, Oreo cookies and some pie crust. Well a little melted butter and sugar to brush and sprinkle on top too
Hello beautiful stack of cookies and peanut butter
Cut out little 4-inch rounds from your pie dough, no need for perfection, just eyeball it.
Press those rounds into your muffin pan.
Now, place that little stack right inside the dough. Easy.
Time for the lattice top. It really is easy, follow my photos below for simple step by step instructions.
See, that wasn’t so bad
Pretty little lattice tops.
Time for a little melted butter then sugar sprinkled on top!
Time to bake em’ at 350 degrees F. for about 25 minutes, until golden.
Can you even stand it?! Lol
Two refrigerated 9 inch pie crusts
16 Oreo Cookies
1 cup creamy peanut butter
2 tablespoons melted butter
2 tablespoons granulated sugar
1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. and spray 8 muffin cups with non stick cooking spray.
2. Unroll pie crusts and cut out eight 4-inch rounds. Press into prepared muffin pan.
3. Spread 1 tablespoon of peanut butter over each cookie then stack 2 cookies on top of each other. Place 2 stacked cookies into pie crusts. With remaining pie dough, cut long thin strips to prepare lattice top. Follow photos to make lattice tops or use a flat piece of dough with slits cut on top.
4. Brush melted butter over tops then sprinkle generously with sugar. Bake for 22-26 minutes, until golden brown. Let cool then remove from pan.
Makes 8 pies
___________________________
Have a great rest of your week! Come back soon!
Welcome to Picky Palate! Kick your feet up and find something good to eat. The recipes you'll see are my creations and The Picky Palate Cookbook is now available! Enjoy!

Finished photos updated Jan 15, 2013 by Jenny Flake
Welcome to the ORIGINAL Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe! You’ll find my recipe that was taken all over the … Continue Reading »









The lattice tops are so cute and you make it look so easy! Another inspired idea – I don’t know where you get them from!
Jenny when I saw these pics on your instagram I about had a heart attack b/c I was sooooo excited. Oreos, PB, mini food (always tastes better!), the little lattices…it was just too much
So happy to have the recipe and once again, you ALWAYS make the best food/desserts that are EASY and not fussy or complicated…thank you!!!
You know what I love about your blog?… Your not afraid to let your reader know you, both what’s on the outside and on the INSIDE!
I love your cross sections.
You are out of control…. in a good way!
SO creative! It’s funny. I was trying to figure out what to do with some peanut butter and oreos I had in the house yesterday and ended up layering the oreo with peanut butter and then wrapping it in chocolate chip cookie dough – and baking. These are adorable though and super creative. Aren’t oreos just fantastic with peanut butter? Mmm mmmmm.
My head just exploded. In a good way.
I LOVE this, and you for making it. Yum!!
oh my goodness, how cute are these?! i love the little lattice on top…and the peanut butter and oreo? duh
Wow! That’s so easy and they look wonderful and complicated! I love them.
They would make excellent christmas exchange cookies. Thank you!
These are adorable! Not to mention tasty too! I love peanut butter and oreos together!
You amaze me with your creations!!!
Wow…these are intense! Yummmmm!
These are ADORABLE! And I can’t believe how simple they look. Way to impress
Oh my GOSH these really should be illegal. Mostly because I would eat that entire cupcake tray. Wow.
The only thing that causes me slight distress is that I have no idea how to make pie crust (I’m terrified of it). I wonder if I could fudge this with some premade crescent roll dough or something similar? Hmm…
Oh my goodness are these not the cutest things ever?!! It’s like a little Oreo-peanut butter pie with no calories because it’s so tiny! I want.
youre so creative i bet your kids love your baking experiments!
Okay, those are pretty darn cute. Have your kids put a crown on your head and proclaimed you “Best Mum Ever” yet?
Wow — these are so adorable!!! I can’t even stand it!
OMG..seriously?! AWESOME!!
MMM these are beautiful, looks wonderful.
oh jenny how i love you and your creativity with the oreo cookie.
keep them coming girl!
These. Look. Amazing. =)
Seriously you are a genious!
I dont think theres any need for me to say ‘ive never seen anything like this before’ because there truly is nothing like this in the world! This is just ingenious and im yet again speechless about your baking imagination
wonndderrffulllll!
Cutest little lattice pies ever
Those are so cute! People will be impressed with those, lol. Do the Oreos get super soft up or do they retain a little bit of their crunch after it’s baked? These look like fun desserts to make!
I was wondering the same thing! Do the oreos get soft?
Wow…these are evil!
Seriously, you need to be locked up! These look amazing.
I think it is amazing that you took such simple ingredients and came up with such a decadent looking and sounding dessert!!
SO cute and dangerous, I’ve got leftover Oreos from the Gooey Cookies n Cream cake bars, they are begging to be used up in this recipe!
me too!!! i can’t wait to make them.
Those are the cutest things I’ve ever seen! Yummy!
This look amazing! So creative and fun!
These are awesome Jenny!
Um. Why do you hate me so much? These are the cutest, easiest looking little pies ever. And SOOOOO indulgent. But they are bite size! Well…a few bites, so perfect portion control, which means they are totally healthy, right? Right. Awesome. Just totally awesome.
ok.. these look crazy fabulous… I sooo can’t believe you didn’t save them for your cookbook
all I can say is WOW!
I love all of your Oreo cookie recipes, always so creative and of course down right delicious looking. I’m guessing you guys really like oreos huh?
I am in love. All of my favorite together and so incredibly beautiful. Where do you get all these ideas!?!
These look amazing. The lattice tops it all of so nicely, too! So indulgent, love it!
These are insane and just too cute! I am a huge pb lover and I have NEVER even thought of eating Oreos with peanut butter, clearly I need to get on that!
Oh My Word! lol I saw this posting pop up on my facebook feed and I literally said that out loud. Speaking of Oreos, off the subject, but I was just recently at Cold Stone over the weekend and they now have an ice cream flavor called “Oreo Cream”, I kid you not! It was A-Mazing! If your feeling extremely crazy, which you can never have too many Oreos, imagine additional Oreos as your add-in…. Yum!
Love it Megan, thanks for the fun tips!
Jenny these are too cute! Seriously Oreo should pay you for all of the recipes you have created for them! : )
I totally agree, lol!
You could probably use Pecan Sandies and butterscotch chips to make a difference variety.
You are an evil genius and I like it! Wow, these sound so amazing!!
Oh my gosh these are adorable! And you’re right, the lattice part does not look that hard. I might make these for my engagement party!!
These look & sounds so ridiculously good!
awesome! i know what i am baking as swoon as the weather cools!
You have inspired the perfect start to many kid friendly receipes just by using ready-made pie crust…lattice pasta bake, lattice chicken bake…lattice tacos
Thanks for the idea…I have to go grocery shopping!!
I can’t get over how ridiculously cute these are.
Oh lord. No wonder my pants wouldn’t button this morning. Just looking at these makes my waist expand! And I will now go to the store for more oreos and pie crust.