Don't miss a single recipe from Picky Palate: sign up for my weekly newsletter


Milky Way Ice Cream

I am so excited for my friend Susan of She’s Becoming Doughmesstic who’s book just came out called The Everything Ice Cream, Gelato, and Frozen Desserts Cookbook.


Susan and I have met at numerous blogging events and I just love her! She is talented and a wonderful person. Wait until you try her ice cream recipes! To die for I tell you ๐Ÿ™‚

Be sure to check out some of my friends who have highlighted Susan’s ice cream recipes from her new book. Susan, Maria, Bree, Brandi, and Paula.

Susan is giving a lucky Picky Palate Reader a copy of her new cookbook and KitchenAid is giving away a fabulous Ice Cream Maker Attachment.

See below on how to enter.






I chose to make Susan’s Milky Way Ice Cream. It is creamy chocolaty and perfect. Make sure you print out the recipe below.

Here’s How To Enter The Giveaway!

Contest is now closed, winner has been notified. Thanks!

1. Leave a comment here and tell us, “What is your favorite kind of ice cream?”

For additional entries:

1. Join Picky Palate and Doughmesstic on Facebook.

2. Follow Picky Palate on Twitter and Pinterest and subscribe to Picky Palate via email. (3 separate comments for these)

3. Contest is over Saturday May 26th 8am PST. Winner will be chosen via and will have 48 hours to return my email. Giveaway open to US Residents only. Giveaway provided by Susan and KitchenAid.


Milky Way Candy Bar Ice Cream

What starts with a simple chocolate ice cream base turns in to a decadent treat with the addition of store bought marshmallow fluff. For extra wow, stir in some chocolate marshmallows and fudge sauce before freezing.

Yield One Quart

3 cups heavy cream

1 cup whole milk

3/4 cup sweetened cocoa powder

3/4 cups sugar

pinch of salt

8 ounces Marshmallow Fluff

1 tablespoon vanilla extract

3 Regular Sized 3 Milky Way Candy Bars

1. Over medium heat, combine milk, cream, cocoa powder, sugar and salt until sugar is dissolved. Remove from heat and add in marshmallow fluff and vanilla. Stir to combine.

2. Allow to chill in refrigerator for 3-4 hours, or overnight.

3. Once chilled, stir in chopped candy bar pieces and add to ice cream maker. Follow manufacturerโ€™s instructions for freezing.

Follow me on instagram

FOLLOW PICKY PALATE ON INSTAGRAM! Show me what recipes you're making from Picky Palate by using #pickypalate.

Comments Leave a Reply
Print Recipe Print Recipe

Powered by MailChimp

Other recipes you may enjoy...


548 Responses | Comments RSS

  1. 501
    Stacey B says:

    I follow PIcky Palate on Facebook

  2. 502
    Caley says:

    Strawberry is the absolute best, but I love cake batter at Coldstone too!

  3. 503
    Mom of 6 says:

    My favorite ice cream is homemade – vanilla with chocolate fudge and peanuts added. Yum Yum.

  4. 504
    Dianna Hansen says:

    Mint Chip!!! Yumm

  5. 505
    Teresa Palmer says:

    My favorite ice cream is homemade vanilla like we had growing up!

  6. 506
    Teresa Palmer says:

    I”liked” Picky Palate on Facebook.

  7. 507
    Teresa Palmer says:

    I “liked” Doughmesstic on Facebook.

  8. 508
    Jill says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip is the best:)

  9. 509
    Teresa Palmer says:

    I subscribed to Picky Palate via e-mail!

  10. 510
    Michael J. McCoy says:

    I follow Picky Palate on Facebook.

  11. 511
    Michael J. McCoy says:

    I follow Doughmesstic on FB.

  12. 512
    Michael J. McCoy says:

    I subscribe to Picky Palate via email.

  13. 513
    Caity H. says:

    My Fav is mint chocolate chip!!

  14. 514
    Caity H. says:

    I have joined picky palate and dougmesstic on facebook.

  15. 515
    Caity H. says:

    I follow Picky Palate on Twitter.

  16. 516
    Caity H. says:

    I follow Picky Palate on Pinterest.

  17. 517
    Caity H. says:

    I can not for the life of me figure out how to subscribe to Picky Palate emails but I would love to!

  18. 518
    Corisa says:

    I’m subscribed to your emails !

  19. 519
    Corisa says:

    my favorite ice cream varies but most of the time its anything with chocolate !

  20. 520
    Kim W says:

    Any kind of ice cream is my favorite, especially home made! ๐Ÿ™‚

  21. 521
    Susan LP says:

    I would have to say chocolate or fresh peach.

  22. 522
    Michelle D says:

    Favorite ice cream is a tie between mint chocolate chip and peanut butter chocolate. Yum!!!

  23. 523
    Michelle D says:

    I’ve joined Picky Palate and Doughmesstic on Facebook!

  24. 524
    Michelle D says:

    I’m now following all of Picky Palate’s pins on Pinterest. ๐Ÿ™‚

  25. 525
    Michelle D says:

    I just subscribed to Picky Palate via email. Thanks!

  26. 526
    Tina C says:

    I love Mint Chocolate Chip

  27. 527
    Tina C says:

    I follow you on Facebook

  28. 528
    Tina C says:

    I follow you on Pinterest!

  29. 529
    Aimee P says:

    Real vanilla bean ice cream, perfection!

  30. 530
    Tiffany says:

    mint chocolate chip

  31. 531
    Carrie says:

    Chocolate, plain and simple ๐Ÿ™‚

  32. 532
    Carrie says:

    I follow you on twitter

  33. 533
    Lynna H. says:

    i follow you on twitter!

  34. 534
    Lynna H. says:

    my favorite type of ice cream is mint chip!

  35. 535
    Ola says:

    My fave icecream are pistaccio! yum :3

  36. 536
    Beth Bartlett says:

    I love Snickers ice cream…..Oh sooooo delish!

  37. 537

    My favorite purchased ice cream is Graeter’s in Cincinnati, toffee chip. My favorite homemade is a close tie between fior di latte, which is a vanilla bean gelato, or Savannah buttermint, which is a recipe of Jenni’s from Columbus, Ohio. Ice cream is my greatest weakness ๐Ÿ˜‰

  38. 538

    My favorite is chocolate peanut butter (or is it peanut butter chocolate?). Second comes vanilla ’cause it tastes so good with any kind of topping.

  39. 539
    Tiffany says:

    Hands down it is mint chocolate chip!

  40. 540
    Megan J says:

    My favorite kind of ice cream is homemade mint oreo!

  41. 541
    Megan J says:

    I follow picky palate on facebook

  42. 542
    Megan J says:

    I follow She’s Becoming DoughMessTic on facebook

  43. 543
    Megan J says:

    I follow picky palate on pinterest

  44. 544
    Melanie N says:

    Anything chocolate with “stuff” added. That milky way recipe is right up my alley!

  45. 545
    Ailene Z says:

    I love ice cream, so my favorites change with the seasons. My new favorite ice cream is Dreyers peanut butter cup.

  46. 546

    […] Velvet Ice Cream from Brown Eyed Baker Chocolate Malt Banana Ice Cream from A Farmgirl's Dabbles Milky Way Candy Bar Ice Cream from Picky Palate Bana-Nutella Chip Ice Cream from Cupcakes and Kale Chips Blueberry Sour Cream Ice […]

  47. 547

    […] Milky Way Ice Cream from Picky Palate […]

Jenny Flake

Welcome to Picky Palate, my online kitchen! You'll usually find me with a cookie in one hand and a salad in the other. It's all about the balance :) The recipes you'll see are my creations. The Picky Palate Cookbook is now available. Enjoy!