Puffy Banana Peanut Butter Cup Sweet Grilled Sandwich

Good morning everyone! Want one of these for breakfast?!

After our family night Monday, I made the boys these fun sweet sammy’s that I had been cooking up in my mind for a week or so. They tasted just as good as I hoped. I mean, what’s not to like with bananas, peanut butter, chocolate and marshmallows? Kind of hard to mess that combo up!

I found that it’s best to wait about 10 minutes before slicing into the sandwich, so the mashmallows don’t ooze out everywhere. Totally worth the wait to give them a little time to firm back up a bit. The warm peanut butter, bananas, melted chocolate and puffed marshmallows seriously melt in your mouth inside the sweet crisp bread!

We’ve got lots going on today, so gotta run, hope everyone has a great rest of the week! Enjoy this crazy puffy sammy! I’ll try to post the fun 60 second lunch soon!

Puffy Banana Peanut Butter Cup Sweet Grilled Sandwich

2 slices whole grain bread
¼ Cup creamy peanut butter
½ banana, cut into thin slices
24-30 mini marshmallows
1 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup, normal size

2 Tablespoons soft butter
Powdered sugar to sprinkle on top

1. Spread peanut butter onto both sides of bread. Lay banana slices over one piece of bread and marshmallows over the other piece, pressing down gently. Break apart the Peanut Butter cup and evenly place in between marshmallows. Carefully lay the bread with banana over the marshmallow side and press gently. Spread butter onto both sides of bread and cook both sides in a medium skillet over medium low heat until golden brown and marshmallows are warm and slightly melted.

2. Let cool for 5-7 minutes before slicing. Sprinkle both sides with powdered sugar and serve warm.

Related Posts

36 Responses
  1. Tahmina

    We’re having breakfast for dinner at my house tonight!!! My kids are going to love this one. Thank you Jenny!

  2. Jaime

    wow, your kids must really love you 🙂 i wonder what some moms think – like the ones that won’t even let their kids eat sugared cereal! luckily, i didn’t have a mom like that growing up…but she also didn’t make stuff like this for me! 😛 your kids are so lucky. another great creation!

  3. carin davis

    I grew up on grilled peanut butter/marshmallow & peanut butter/banana…the combination! WOW!

  4. RecipeGirl

    You’re the best mommy ever 🙂

    I daresay that my 7 year old would absolutely love this treat!!

  5. maine626

    can i come over for lunch??? and i think you have a slight obsession with banana’s & PB!! which i’m kinda liking!

  6. www.adorn-jewelry.blogspot.com

    JENNY! What are you doing to us? This looks so amazingly delicious! you and your peanut butter concoctions are just too much!! yum!

  7. Julie

    Goodness Gracious!! After making that for your boys, you are definitely mom of the year!! So many good things wrapped up in one delicious package.

  8. Catherine Wilkinson

    That’s SO over the top, Jenny!
    Whoa! My teeth hurt just looking at it! Wonderful!

  9. Adam

    Wow. I don’t think that sandwich could be have anymore filling in it. It’s like it went to an all-you-can-eat buffet… and they were serving sweetness.

  10. Steph

    Oh. My. My daughter would be in peanut butter and marshmallow heaven if I made one of these for her. She would love me forever!

  11. Fat & Sassy

    OH MY STARS!!! That looks so yummy, we’ll be trying that for sure…I just wonder how many wieght watcher points it is…yikes!

  12. My Sweet & Saucy

    If that doesn’t look good I don’t know what does! Those photos are making me want a bite!

  13. One Wired Woman

    Yum!! I really love your blog. I actually put it in my “Cool Things” section. My eight year old is very picky and I’m always looking for new recipes. 🙂 Jill

  14. Rachelle

    Oh my my! Something I know we’d all eat (all except for the littlest, he’s allergic to PB). Yum!

  15. Deborah

    I would be in heaven if I was a kid! And actually, my husband loves to make peanut butter marshmallow grilled sandwiches, so I’m sure throwing in banana and chocolate make it even better!

  16. NatNibbles

    Whoa! That sounds like the most amazing breakfast…I’ll be making it this weekend for sure.

  17. Kim and George

    Oh my Jenny! I can totally see what I’ll be eating ALL day today:) Too bad there isn’t a pilates mat class tonight.

Welcome to Picky Palate!

Picky PalateWelcome to my online kitchen! You'll usually find me with a cookie in one hand & a salad in the other. It's all about the balance :) The recipes you'll see are my creations. Enjoy!

Recipe Categories